• SUBSCRIBE
Athlon Outdoors Supersite
Tactical Life Website
Ballistic Website
Personal Defense World Website
Skillsetmag Website
  • Guns
    • Handguns
      • Semi-Automatic Handguns
      • Revolvers
    • AR Pistols
    • AR Rifles
    • Rifles
      • Semi-Automatic Rifles
      • Lever Action
      • Bolt Action
    • Shotguns
    • Airguns
    • Custom Guns
      • Handgun Build
      • Rifle Build
      • Shotgun Build
    • Specialty Guns
  • Parts
    • Handgun Parts
    • Rifle Parts
  • Accessories
    • Optics & Sights
    • Lasers & Lights
    • Suppressors
    • Holsters
    • Slings
    • Shooting Rests
    • Targets
    • Maintenance & Tools
  • Ammo
    • Handgun Ammo
      • 9mm
      • 10mm
    • Rifle Ammo
      • .223
    • Shotgun Ammo
      • 12 Gauge
    • Rimfire Ammo
    • Reloading
  • Gear
    • Apparel
    • Ears & Eyes
      • Ears
      • Eyes
        • Thermal Vision
        • Night Vision
    • Storage
    • Tactical Gear
      • Body Armor
    • Knives
      • Fixed Blade
      • Folding Knives
      • Tactical Knives
    • Less Lethal
    • Flashlights
    • Electronics
  • Lifestyle
    • Concealed Carry
    • Personal Defense
      • Self-Defense
      • Hand to Hand Combat
    • Home Defense
    • Sport Shooting
      • Hunting
      • Competition Shooting
    • Precision Shooting/Long Range Shooting
    • Training
      • Shooting 101
    • Survival
      • First Aid
    • Tactical & LE
    • Pop Culture
      • People
      • Rides
      • History
      • Military Lifestyle
  • News
    • New Products & Industry News
    • Gun Facts & Laws
    • Police News
    • Military News
    • Politics
  • VIDEOS
No Result
View All Result
Athlon Outdoors
  • Guns
    • Handguns
      • Semi-Automatic Handguns
      • Revolvers
    • AR Pistols
    • AR Rifles
    • Rifles
      • Semi-Automatic Rifles
      • Lever Action
      • Bolt Action
    • Shotguns
    • Airguns
    • Custom Guns
      • Handgun Build
      • Rifle Build
      • Shotgun Build
    • Specialty Guns
  • Parts
    • Handgun Parts
    • Rifle Parts
  • Accessories
    • Optics & Sights
    • Lasers & Lights
    • Suppressors
    • Holsters
    • Slings
    • Shooting Rests
    • Targets
    • Maintenance & Tools
  • Ammo
    • Handgun Ammo
      • 9mm
      • 10mm
    • Rifle Ammo
      • .223
    • Shotgun Ammo
      • 12 Gauge
    • Rimfire Ammo
    • Reloading
  • Gear
    • Apparel
    • Ears & Eyes
      • Ears
      • Eyes
        • Thermal Vision
        • Night Vision
    • Storage
    • Tactical Gear
      • Body Armor
    • Knives
      • Fixed Blade
      • Folding Knives
      • Tactical Knives
    • Less Lethal
    • Flashlights
    • Electronics
  • Lifestyle
    • Concealed Carry
    • Personal Defense
      • Self-Defense
      • Hand to Hand Combat
    • Home Defense
    • Sport Shooting
      • Hunting
      • Competition Shooting
    • Precision Shooting/Long Range Shooting
    • Training
      • Shooting 101
    • Survival
      • First Aid
    • Tactical & LE
    • Pop Culture
      • People
      • Rides
      • History
      • Military Lifestyle
  • News
    • New Products & Industry News
    • Gun Facts & Laws
    • Police News
    • Military News
    • Politics
  • VIDEOS
No Result
View All Result
Athlon Outdoors Super Site
No Result
View All Result
  • TL
  • PDW
  • BM
  • Skillset
 
ENTER TO WIN: FREE GUN FRIDAY ft. Browning, Caldwell & Black Hills!

Massad Ayoob: Understanding Stand Your Ground & Castle Doctrine

ShareTweetPin
massad ayoob, castle doctrine, stand your ground, castle doctrine law, stand your ground law
Massad AyoobbyMassad Ayoob
February 2, 2016
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
massad ayoob, castle doctrine, stand your ground, castle doctrine law, stand your ground law
massad ayoob, castle doctrine, stand your ground, castle doctrine law, stand your ground law, stand your ground self-defense
massad ayoob, castle doctrine, stand your ground, castle doctrine law, stand your ground law, stand your ground defense

massad ayoob, castle doctrine, stand your ground, castle doctrine law, stand your ground law, castle doctrine defense
massad ayoob, castle doctrine, stand your ground, castle doctrine law, stand your ground law, castle doctrine self-defense
massad ayoob, castle doctrine, stand your ground, castle doctrine law, stand your ground law, stand your ground shooting

massad ayoob, castle doctrine, stand your ground, castle doctrine law, stand your ground law, castle doctrine vs. stand your ground
massad ayoob, castle doctrine, stand your ground, castle doctrine law, stand your ground law, pistol
massad ayoob, castle doctrine, stand your ground, castle doctrine law, stand your ground law, concealed carry pistol

massad ayoob, castle doctrine, stand your ground, castle doctrine law, stand your ground law, concealed carry handguns

In a nation that has become a sound-bite society, we have a public and therefore a jury pool that is increasingly vulnerable to simplistic, misinformed answers to complicated questions. This has certainly been true in recent years, with print and electronic media having disseminated false perceptions about such topics as Castle Doctrine and Stand Your Ground laws.

We are told on editorial pages that with these laws in place, anyone can kill anyone and get away with it by claiming “I was in fear for my life.” We are told that this allows criminals to commit murder and get away with it by uttering the magic words, “It was self-defense.” We are told that with these laws rivers of blood will run in the streets, that both malicious and negligent shootings will go un-punished in the civil courts, and that homicides will rise and are already rising as a direct result. The facts, however, show otherwise.

Clarity

massad ayoob, castle doctrine, stand your ground, castle doctrine law, stand your ground law, castle doctrine self-defense

Castle Doctrine derives from the ancient principle in the English Common Law that held that the individual’s home is his castle; attacked there, he need not retreat, and even the king could not enter the cottage of the most humble peasant without a warrant. While the latter element touches on Fourth Amendment issues not on point to the topic of the moment, “a man’s home is his castle” is so well established that it has long since entered daily American idiom.

The doctrine speaks to home and curtilage: The house or apartment itself, and attached or adjacent buildings; actual definitions of “curtilage” may vary in case law on a state-by-state basis. Normally, however, it will not extend to the front lawn, the sidewalk or the far boundaries of one’s farm or ranch.

RELATED STORY: Massad Ayoob – Deadly Force From A Position of Disadvantage

Castle Doctrine issues can be murky. In one famous case in New England in the mid-1970s, Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Roberta Shaffer, a state supreme court held that a woman who shot her common-law husband when he attacked her in their home was not covered because the home was his, too, and therefore her invocation of the Castle Doctrine was not applicable. In 2012, however, in State of Nebraska v. Darrel White, the Nebraska State Supreme Court upheld a man’s right to, without retreat, kill the roommate who violently attacked him in the abode they both shared.

Stand Your Ground (SYG) laws are geared toward confrontations that occur outside the home, since they would be redundant to Castle Doctrine, which already makes it clear that the individual need not retreat before using defensive deadly force against a home invader. SYG protects a person only if: (1) He was not the aggressor, or if he was, has attempted to break off hostilities before the second party’s attack on him now necessitates your client’s use of deadly force; (2) He was in a place where he had a right to be; (3) He was not committing a crime at the time.

Since the passage of the relevant Texas law authored by State Senator Jeff Wentworth, retreat has not been required before resorting to deadly force if the latter is necessary. However, even prior, retreat has never been demanded unless it could be accomplished with complete safety to oneself and others. This is true in Texas, and has long been true in the rest of the country as well, including the so called “retreat states.”

massad ayoob, castle doctrine, stand your ground, castle doctrine law, stand your ground law, stand your ground defense

It is imperative that you know the difference. As you know, self-defense is an affirmative defense, which shifts the burden of proof. In most jurisdictions, for a self-defense plea to prevail, the defense will have to convince the triers of the facts to a preponderance of evidence standard that the shooting was indeed justified. This burden, vastly higher than merely creating an element of reasonable doubt as to his guilt, is far more easily met if the defendant takes the stand. After all, you are stipulating that he shot the deceased; the issue is why he did so. Was his purpose malicious or justifiable? You can say whatever you want in an opening statement, but by the time you’re ready to close, you have to introduce testimony or evidence to back up any assertions you make at the opening. If your client doesn’t take the stand, who else can testify as to what his purpose was when he pulled the trigger?

Since there is therefore a high likelihood that your client will take the stand, it is important for you to have schooled him in the difference between Castle Doctrine and SYG. Suppose your client was attacked by a knife-wielding mugger in a public park, and instead of attempting to retreat, drew his legally carried gun and shot the assailant dead. During cross-examination, opposing counsel may ask him, “Mr. Defendant, what do you believe justified you using a gun on him without at least attempting to just run away without bloodshed?” If your client makes the mistake of giving a “Castle Doctrine” answer, opposing counsel has your man in a very disadvantaged position.

I would expect the opposing lawyer to hand him a copy of Black’s Legal Dictionary and have your client read the definition of Castle Doctrine to the jury. Then, your opposite number will pounce. “So, Mr. Defendant, it’s the home that’s the castle. But this shooting took place in a park. Are you telling this jury you consider the park to be your castle grounds? Who was it, exactly, who made you the king of all the rest of us?”

This is why it’s important for anyone who carries a gun to know the specific differences between Castle Doctrine and Stand Your Ground.

Justified Or Not?

massad ayoob, castle doctrine, stand your ground, castle doctrine law, stand your ground law, stand your ground shooting

Since late in the first quarter of 2012, when a shooting in Sanford, Florida, captured the headlines, that state’s law is the one that has received the most popular discussion. Passed in 2005, this law not only clarified Castle Doctrine in the Sunshine State, and rescinded the previous retreat requirement, but also provided for a presumption of innocence element. The defendant can request a hearing (in this case, more of a mini-trial) in which a judge who determines the act to have, more likely than not, been justified, may dismiss the case.

RELATED STORY: 6 Must-Know Court Cases For Gun Owners

Texas, like Florida, has a provision in its law that if the shooting has been determined to be justified, the shooter should be immune to civil lawsuit. It is reasonable to assume that an allegation of negligence by the plaintiff may, if credibly presented, bypass this protection, since, by definition, there can be no justifiable accident. In one case now proceeding through the civil system in Florida, the state’s attorney has chosen not to pursue the matter of a young man who killed a burglar who was menacing him and his mother. However, that prosecutor’s office has not yet issued a memorandum of closure declaring this use of deadly force to have been justified. At this point the lawsuit is still alive and well, and progressing toward trial since it has not, by definition, been “determined” to have been justified.

In Tyler, Texas, in February of 2007, rancher Terry Graham came home to catch a drug-addicted, longtime felon and burglar leaving Graham’s freshly looted house. When the homeowner challenged him, the burglar gunned his getaway car at Graham with his left hand on the steering wheel and his right hand reaching into a bag of stolen guns. Graham fired a single shot. The shot killed the assailant and undoubtedly saved Graham’s life and perhaps the lives of two other people who were with the homeowner.

massad ayoob, castle doctrine, stand your ground, castle doctrine law, stand your ground law, castle doctrine defense

I spoke for him in front of the grand jury convened by a fair district attorney, Matt Bingham. They no-billed. The family of the deceased sued. Attorney Tracy Crawford called Albert Rodriguez and me as experts for the defense at trial in July of 2009. The jury found entirely for defendant Terry Graham. By then, however, Mr. Graham had amassed substantial legal fees and been placed under tremendous stress for nearly two and a half years.

It was to prevent such obvious injustices that the Texas state legislature passed its law creating civil liability immunity for justified use of deadly physical force. However, that law did not go into effect until September of 2007, some seven months after Mr. Graham had to fire in what was later clearly shown to be legitimate self-defense. Tracy Crawford and many other Texas attorneys felt that if the law had been in place at the time of the Graham incident, much unnecessary grief might have been saved.

While the Castle Doctrine and Stand Your Ground principles are mature, long-established concepts in law, the civil immunity provisions in Texas and Florida law are fairly recent. They have not been tested all the way up through the appellate process. In Texas, it remains less than perfectly clear as to what “deems” the use of fatal force justifiable for purposes of civil immunity.

Stand Your Ground

massad ayoob, castle doctrine, stand your ground, castle doctrine law, stand your ground law, concealed carry pistol

Will an increase in justifiable homicides in states with SYG laws mean that more lives are being lost? Not necessarily. Historian Clayton Cramer noted that when Time magazine did a story on every death by gunfire for one week in America, and returned a year later to follow up on the outcomes, a significant number of those fatal shootings that had originally been implied to be criminal homicides turned out to be justified self-defense incidents.

Cramer cited one study in which justifiable homicides by armed citizens had increased three-fold—but so had justified officer-involved shootings in the same region. The change in law as it affected citizens certainly didn’t change anything from the police side. Cramer considers it logical to conclude that, within the studied population, violent activity by criminals warranting the defensive use of deadly force had simply increased.

RELATED STORY: Beating the ‘Rambo’ Rap – How to Explain a Self-Defense Shooting in Court

The recent Texas A&M University study on homicides as related to Stand Your Ground laws notes, “This indicates that, in addition, we look at justifiable homicide, which is a separate classification available in the Supplemental Homicide Reports. One concern with these data is underreporting; Kleck (1988) estimates that only one-fifth of legally justified homicides are classified that way by police.” Many shootings that previously had to go to trial to determine justifiability—at the expense of many tax dollars, and much human suffering by the wrongly accused and their families—are now simply found justifiable earlier. Far from being a bad thing, early determination of justifiability reduces the cost in public treasure and private trauma, and better serves justice in both respects.

Will criminals kill people and get away with it by claiming self-defense? Obviously not, as evidenced by the jury’s recent verdict in Texas v. Raul Rodriguez. Skilled prosecutors have been winning convictions against murderers who falsely claimed self-defense for as long as there have been murder trials. One need look no farther than the 2012 conviction for murder of Raul Rodriguez, the Houston-area man who went to a loud neighbor’s house with a video camera and a gun, and as the prosecutor told the jury in her opening statement, used every “CHL buzzword” in an incident that escalated until he had shot three men, killing one. Despite his on-camera statements of “I am standing my ground” and “I am in fear of my life,” the Houston jury saw it as a malicious setup. Mr. Rodriguez is now serving a long prison sentence.

massad ayoob, castle doctrine, stand your ground, castle doctrine law, stand your ground law, castle doctrine vs. stand your ground

Will the families of men killed in SYG self-defense shootings be denied civil justice because of the civil immunity clauses? No. A finding of self-defense at the hearing level means that justifiability has already been proven to a preponderance of evidence. Wrongful killings are exempt from immunity, a fact obvious to anyone who reads actual laws instead of newspaper headlines or the catchphrases created by people with agendas.

Will Stand Your Ground laws mean that cops will slough off investigations of homicides as soon as the shooter claims self-defense? No, and with 38 years of carrying a badge, I take personal offense at that false allegation. “The death of a citizen” is a top-tier priority for law enforcement and the prosecutorial bar alike, and it is a gross insult to suggest that either entity would cut corners in the investigation of any homicide.

The conscientious police and prosecutors of America know that their duty is as much to exonerate the innocent as to punish the guilty. The recent changes in the law from Texas to Florida to other parts of the country simply reinforce the principles of justified use of lethal force for the protection of the innocent from violent criminal assaults.

The bottom line is simple: Sometimes criminals are so violent that there is no way to stop them but with deadly force. It happens for cops, security professionals and armed citizens.

Note: The author originally presented this material during the Texas Bar Association’s 2013 Texas Firearms Law Seminar.

Didn't find what you were looking for?

MOST POPULAR

Taurus Home Defender revolver in .410.

KA-BOOM: Here Comes the Taurus Judge Home Defender!

300 Blackout vs 308, rifles, ammunition

300 Blackout vs 308 Win: Which Round Reigns Supreme in AR-15s?

Police Sidearms, police duty pistols, Handguns, America's Largest Police Departments 2018

Police Sidearms: Handguns of America’s 10 Largest Departments

All the best new handguns seen at SHOT Show 2023.

21 Best New Handguns [2023]

TRENDING

Taurus 25PLY .25 ACP

Mesa Tactical Urbino Tactical Stock System

Gun Annual 2016 sound suppressors Yankee Hill Machine Sidewinder

17 Covert Sound Suppressors For Plinking, Practice & More

Fightlite Raider, lead

Fightlite Raider: The Sci-Fi Pistol With Intriguing Defense Capabilities

Sharps Bros Heatseeker Chassis, Ruger American Rifle, lead

Sharps Bros Heatseeker Chassis Transforms the Ruger American Rifle

BROWSE BY BRAND

Skillset-Logo_yellow-153x47png
Ballistic_LOGO-217x47
CH-Logo_blue-153x47
T-L-SS-stack life-47x140
PDW_CCH_LOGO-300x101
PDW-2022-Sidebyside-logo 160x30-blk
GOW LOGO x101
AF_LOGO-184x47

SPOTLIGHT

The Taurus GX4 Carry.

Taurus GX4 Carry Finds the Balance Between Capacity and Carry

Taurus USA has really created quite a stir in the industry over the past few years with all the new...

RELATED POSTS

The Taurus GX4 Carry.

Taurus GX4 Carry Finds the Balance Between Capacity and Carry

...

The 21st Tec TEC47 Rifle.

The 21st Tec TEC47 AR-10 in 7.62x39mm Accepts AK Mags

...

The Sig Sauer P320 FCU and Custom Shop circumvent restrictive state regulations.

Sig P320 FCU and Custom Shop Overcome Restrictive State Laws

...

Load More

TRENDING

Harley WLA 1951 Panhead Repro Bravo Company Paul Buffoni lead

A Look at Paul Buffoni’s Military-Based Harley WLA 1951 Panhead Repro

The mechanics of motorcycles led Paul Buffoni, a retired Marine, to found Bravo Company Manufacturing in 2006. "I started riding...

Bradley Cooper as Chris Kyle in American Sniper.

Reel Shooters: The Best Movie Snipers & a Few of the Worst

Fans of action and war movies would be forgiven for thinking that trained snipers carry their rifles disassembled in an...

Big Horn Armory AR500 review, .500 Auto Max Semi-Auto AR

Big Horn Armory AR500: Testing the Absurdly Powerful AR in .500 Auto Max

The start of a new century seemed to wake up designers in their quest to expand AR roles via caliber...

holster, holsters, full-size pistol, full-size handgun, handgun, handguns, pistol, pistols

Practical Concealed Carry: How to Carry A Full-Size Pistol

Given that your carry weapon is a lifesaving tool, carrying a full-size pistol just may be the best decision you...

MOST POPULAR

The Mossberg MC2sc semi-auto pistol.

12 Best Micro-Compact Handguns for Concealed Carry [2022]

A thick veil of fog stood forever in front of me as I cruised down the highway at 6:30 in...

Police Sidearms, police duty pistols, Handguns, America's Largest Police Departments 2018

Police Sidearms: Handguns of America’s 10 Largest Departments

Law enforcement in the United States is in constant evolution and that includes various police sidearms. These days, law enforcement...

U.S. Secret Service adopts Glock G47

FIRST LOOK: Glock Just Very Quietly Unveiled the New Glock 47 Pistol

Tuesday afternoon we broke news that the U.S. Customs and Border Protection selected three Glock 9mm pistols as its new standard...

All the best new handguns seen at SHOT Show 2023.

21 Best New Handguns [2023]

The NSSF SHOT Show is the premier event to get your hands on new gear. It gives us a first...

VIDEO SERIES: AT THE READY | SEASON 2

MORE VIDEOS

The Taurus GX4 Carry.

Taurus GX4 Carry Finds the Balance Between Capacity and Carry

The 21st Tec TEC47 Rifle.

The 21st Tec TEC47 AR-10 in 7.62x39mm Accepts AK Mags

HANDGUNS

The Taurus GX4 Carry.

Taurus GX4 Carry Finds the Balance Between Capacity and Carry

The Sig Sauer P320 FCU and Custom Shop circumvent restrictive state regulations.

Sig P320 FCU and Custom Shop Overcome Restrictive State Laws

New Graphene finish.

The Taurus GX4 Micro-Compact is Now Available in Graphene

The Pedersoli Howdah.

The Pedersoli Howdah: Recreating the Howdah’s Legacy

The SK Customs Morelos.

SK Customs Morelos 1911 Heralds Generalissimo Jose Morelos

The Tisas Model 1911A1 Aviator

Tisas 1911A1 Aviator: Bringing Back the ‘Feel’ of the Original

RIFLES - click to see all

The 21st Tec TEC47 Rifle.

The 21st Tec TEC47 AR-10 in 7.62x39mm Accepts AK Mags

The Watchtower Type 15M.

Watchtower Type 15M is Premium Forged and “All American Made”

The Heritage Tactical Rancher Carbine.

Heritage Tactical Rancher Carbine Brings the .22 LR and Mag Fun

The limited edition RISE Armament Topo Watchman rifle.

UPDATED: New RISE Armament Topo Watchman Limited-Edition

AMMO - click to see all

HEVI-Shot HEVI-Bismuth Upland loads.

HEVI-Shot HEVI-Bismuth Upland Expands Hunting Lineup

Ammo Storage, Survival Ammo, long term ammo storage, Prepper

Best Methods for Long-Term Ammo Storage

6 .410 Ammo Options for Home and Personal Defense.

.410 Ammo for Home Defense [2023]

.44 Magnum dirty harry

Your Guide to the .44 Magnum Cartridge

The Escort PS Youth 20-gauge shotgun.

The Escort PS Youth Shotgun is Now Available in .410 Bore

The 2022 Athlon Outdoors Rendezvous event.

Rendezvous Roundup: Guns & Gear at Athlon’s Signature Event

Magazines Available Now! Subscribe today for Home Delivery!
FREE NEWSLETTERS! Subscribe!
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • TERMS OF USE
  • CORPORATE
  • ADVERTISE
  • EDIT DESK
No Result
View All Result
  • Guns
    • Handguns
      • Semi-Automatic Handguns
      • Revolvers
    • AR Pistols
    • AR Rifles
    • Rifles
      • Semi-Automatic Rifles
      • Lever Action
      • Bolt Action
    • Shotguns
    • Airguns
    • Custom Guns
      • Handgun Build
      • Rifle Build
      • Shotgun Build
    • Specialty Guns
  • Parts
    • Handgun Parts
    • Rifle Parts
  • Accessories
    • Optics & Sights
    • Lasers & Lights
    • Suppressors
    • Holsters
    • Slings
    • Shooting Rests
    • Targets
    • Maintenance & Tools
  • Ammo
    • Handgun Ammo
      • 9mm
      • 10mm
    • Rifle Ammo
      • .223
    • Shotgun Ammo
      • 12 Gauge
    • Rimfire Ammo
    • Reloading
  • Gear
    • Apparel
    • Ears & Eyes
      • Ears
      • Eyes
    • Storage
    • Tactical Gear
      • Body Armor
    • Knives
      • Fixed Blade
      • Folding Knives
      • Tactical Knives
    • Less Lethal
    • Flashlights
    • Electronics
  • Lifestyle
    • Concealed Carry
    • Personal Defense
      • Self-Defense
      • Hand to Hand Combat
    • Home Defense
    • Sport Shooting
      • Hunting
      • Competition Shooting
    • Precision Shooting/Long Range Shooting
    • Training
      • Shooting 101
    • Survival
      • First Aid
    • Tactical & LE
    • Pop Culture
      • People
      • Rides
      • History
      • Military Lifestyle
  • News
    • New Products & Industry News
    • Gun Facts & Laws
    • Police News
    • Military News
    • Politics
  • VIDEOS

© 2023 Athlon Outdoors - Premium Firearm product and industry news, reviews and magazines" .