Athlon Outdoors Supersite
Tactical Life Website
Ballistic Website
Personal Defense World Website
Skillsetmag Website
  • Guns
    • Handguns
      • Semi-Automatic Handguns
      • Revolvers
    • AR Pistols
    • AR Rifles
    • Rifles
      • Semi-Automatic Rifles
      • Lever Action
      • Bolt Action
    • Shotguns
    • Airguns
    • Custom Guns
      • Handgun Build
      • Rifle Build
      • Shotgun Build
    • Specialty Guns
  • Parts
    • Handgun Parts
    • Rifle Parts
  • Accessories
    • Optics & Sights
      • Thermal Vision
    • Lasers & Lights
    • Suppressors
    • Holsters
    • Slings
    • Shooting Rests
    • Targets
    • Maintenance & Tools
  • Ammo
    • Handgun Ammo
      • 9mm
      • 10mm
    • Rifle Ammo
      • .223
    • Shotgun Ammo
      • 12 Gauge
    • Rimfire Ammo
    • Reloading
  • Gear
    • Apparel
    • Ears & Eyes
      • Ears
      • Eyes
        • Night Vision
    • Storage
    • Tactical Gear
      • Body Armor
    • Knives
      • Fixed Blade
      • Folding Knives
      • Tactical Knives
    • Less Lethal
    • Flashlights
    • Electronics
  • Lifestyle
    • Concealed Carry
    • Personal Defense
      • Self-Defense
      • Hand to Hand Combat
    • Home Defense
    • Sport Shooting
      • Hunting
      • Competition Shooting
    • Precision Shooting/Long Range Shooting
    • Training
      • Shooting 101
    • Survival
      • First Aid
    • Tactical & LE
    • Military Lifestyle
    • Pop Culture
      • People
      • Rides
      • History
  • News
    • New Products & Industry News
    • Gun Facts & Laws
    • Police News
    • Military News
    • Politics
  • VIDEOS
No Result
View All Result
Athlon Outdoors
  • Guns
    • Handguns
      • Semi-Automatic Handguns
      • Revolvers
    • AR Pistols
    • AR Rifles
    • Rifles
      • Semi-Automatic Rifles
      • Lever Action
      • Bolt Action
    • Shotguns
    • Airguns
    • Custom Guns
      • Handgun Build
      • Rifle Build
      • Shotgun Build
    • Specialty Guns
  • Parts
    • Handgun Parts
    • Rifle Parts
  • Accessories
    • Optics & Sights
      • Thermal Vision
    • Lasers & Lights
    • Suppressors
    • Holsters
    • Slings
    • Shooting Rests
    • Targets
    • Maintenance & Tools
  • Ammo
    • Handgun Ammo
      • 9mm
      • 10mm
    • Rifle Ammo
      • .223
    • Shotgun Ammo
      • 12 Gauge
    • Rimfire Ammo
    • Reloading
  • Gear
    • Apparel
    • Ears & Eyes
      • Ears
      • Eyes
        • Night Vision
    • Storage
    • Tactical Gear
      • Body Armor
    • Knives
      • Fixed Blade
      • Folding Knives
      • Tactical Knives
    • Less Lethal
    • Flashlights
    • Electronics
  • Lifestyle
    • Concealed Carry
    • Personal Defense
      • Self-Defense
      • Hand to Hand Combat
    • Home Defense
    • Sport Shooting
      • Hunting
      • Competition Shooting
    • Precision Shooting/Long Range Shooting
    • Training
      • Shooting 101
    • Survival
      • First Aid
    • Tactical & LE
    • Military Lifestyle
    • Pop Culture
      • People
      • Rides
      • History
  • News
    • New Products & Industry News
    • Gun Facts & Laws
    • Police News
    • Military News
    • Politics
  • VIDEOS
No Result
View All Result
Athlon Outdoors Super Site
No Result
View All Result
  • TL
  • PDW
  • BM
  • Skillset
 
ENTER TO WIN: Smith & Wesson's Free Gun Friday Package ft. Caldwell, Volcon, and Black Hills

5 Cases Where The Attacker’s Violent Past Meant Zero During Trial

ShareTweetPin
self-defense, self defense, self defense cases, massad ayoob, massed ayoob self defense
Massad AyoobbyMassad Ayoob
November 5, 2014
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
self-defense, self defense, self defense cases, massad ayoob, massed ayoob self defense
self-defense, self defense, self defense cases, massad ayoob, massed ayoob self defense
self-defense, self defense, self defense cases, massad ayoob, massed ayoob self defense

self-defense, self defense, self defense cases, massad ayoob, massed ayoob self defense
self-defense, self defense, self defense cases, massad ayoob, massed ayoob self defense

Lawfully armed citizens have much of their identity invested in being the good guy, and tend to assume that society and the courts will recognize their assailants as the bad guys. But it doesn’t always work out that way.

Case One: Massachusetts. A young college student is walking home after a pleasant evening having a few drinks with friends. He is attacked without provocation by a couple of “townies,” the most aggressive of whom is kicking him savagely as he struggles to rise from his hands and knees. Fearing that he’s about to be stomped to death, he draws his daily carry pocketknife, a Spyderco Military. He slashes blindly into the darkness behind him, trying to scare the attacker away. Instead, the blade finds its way into the attacker’s chest, mortally wounding him.

The dead assailant turns out to have a history of this exact kind of unprovoked attack. However, the jury is never allowed to know this, and the young man who defended himself is convicted of manslaughter.

Case Two: Arizona. A retired schoolteacher hiking in the desert is attacked by a couple of vicious dogs, and he draws his pistol and fires warning shots. The dogs are smart enough to back off and stop attacking. Their owner is not. Larger, younger and stronger than the teacher, the dog owner rushes at the teacher in an obvious state of rage, screaming threats. At the last moment—at powder-burning distance—the teacher fires. It takes three 10mm bullets to stop the attacker, who falls, mortally wounded.

RELATED: 6 Self-Defense Court Cases You Need To Know

The investigation shows that the dead man had a long history of violent mental illness, including multiple vicious attacks like the one described by the hiker. But the hiker, who had never seen the man before, didn’t know that. The jury that judged the teacher is not allowed to know it either…and they convict him of second-degree murder.

self-defense, self defense, self defense cases, massad ayoob, massed ayoob self defense

Case Three: Massachusetts. A young woman who works for an escort service winds up with a customer who becomes enraged when she won’t have sex with him. Threatened and then struck with a crowbar, she gets her hand on a knife and lashes back. Her attacker dies of the knife wounds.

RELATED: Vigilant or Vigilante? Four Cases of Armed Citizens Leaving the Home

You guessed it: The dead man turns out to have attacked others in the past, in much the same way. And, you guessed it again, because she didn’t know it at the time she knifed him, the jurors aren’t allowed to know it either, and the jury convicts her of manslaughter.

Interwoven in the dangerous fantasy meme of “a good shoot is a good shoot” is the presumption that the jury will automatically recognize you as the good guy, and the criminal who forced you to shoot him in self-defense will be equally recognizable as a bad guy. I’ve heard people say things like, “When the jury finds out all the rotten things the bad guy did to build his criminal record, they’ll understand why I had to pull the trigger.”

Uh, no. That is not very likely at all in most jurisdictions.

In the majority of jurisdictions, prior bad acts by your opponent, if they were not known to you at the time you shot him in self-defense, will not be allowed to go in front of the jury.

Evidence Rule 404(b)

The prohibition of prior bad acts from the jury’s consideration tracks to Federal Rule 404(b). At the state level there will be some version of this rule, sometimes with the same number. Rule 404(b) instructs in part, “Evidence of other crimes, wrongs, or acts is not admissible to prove the character of a person in order to show action in conformity therewith.”

RELATED: Stand Your Ground Laws & Legalities – 5 Real-Life Cases

We have to understand the rationale of this rule. We are being judged for our act, which, in a self-defense shooting, is the use of deadly force on another human being. Essentially, the issue is whether we used sound, lawful judgment in performing that act. If we didn’t know about the attacker’s prior bad acts, they were not formative to the decision for which we are being judged. Therefore, since we did not have that knowledge when we took action, the jury will not be allowed to have it either. Fortunately, there are exceptions. Let’s look at them.

self-defense, self defense, self defense cases, massad ayoob, massed ayoob self defense

Exceptions

Oh, wait—you’ve already seen the exceptions. That’s right, all three of the convictions mentioned above were reversed on appeal at the state Supreme Court level. They are now case law: Case One was Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Alexander Pring-Wilson, Case Two was State of Arizona v. Harold Fish, and Case Three was Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Rhonda Adjutant.

Obviously, case law emanating from a state Supreme Court is only binding in that particular state. However, these three precedents can be offered by your attorney as persuasive argument during motions in limine, which the judge may consider prior to trial to determine what evidence will and will not be allowed in your particular trial. It is also within judicial prerogative for the judge to set aside Rule 404b or its equivalent, but this normally requires the prosecution to “open the door.”

RELATED: Self-Defense & The Law – Staying Alive

In Case Four, in Florida, the prosecution had presented the deceased as an innocent 20-year-old with a clean criminal record, someone who never would have pulled a gun on police as testified by the officer who shot and killed him and wound up charged with manslaughter. The officer was defended by two brilliant lawyers, Roy Black and Mark Seiden. The defense presented a 40-page memorandum of law that convinced the trial judge to set aside 404b so the jury could hear from an elderly woman who was robbed and brutalized by the deceased. They won an acquittal, and that woman’s testimony sure didn’t hurt. In years since, many other attorneys have taken this approach, often working from the same memorandum, to allow juries to see the true faces of dead criminals who forced decent people to shoot them in self-defense.

self-defense, self defense, self defense cases, massad ayoob, massed ayoob self defense

Today’s Reality

Things are not as we wish them to be; things are as they are. In most jurisdictions, you can’t expect the jury to know of prior bad acts by your opponent if the time comes when that jury must judge you for shooting that opponent. Only if you knew of your opponent’s previous crimes will you be able to introduce them. That’s because that knowledge is relevant—indeed, maybe foundational—to your decision to use force against him as a last resort.

The fact is, even if you live in Massachusetts with the Adjutant and Pring-Wilson precedents, or Arizona with the Fish precedent, there are no guarantees.

RELATED: Massad Ayoob’s Tips and Tactics for Staying Alert and Aware

Case Five, Arizona: A young husband and father is attacked in his front yard by three people. One is a tall, physically strong woman who studies Brazilian jiu-jitsu and writes on her Facebook page, “I love to grapple.” Another is a buff male who spends a lot of time in a gym and sees himself as a future Navy SEAL. Being beaten, feeling himself about to lose consciousness, the victim draws his Glock 19 and fires, wounding both of the individuals described. He is charged with aggravated assault. The jury deadlocks in his first trial in Tucson. By the time of his second trial, the Fish precedent has come down, but the judge still refuses to allow the facts about his opponents’ abilities to cause harm to go in front of the jury. After a second hung jury, the prosecution gives up and the young man gets his life back.

Bottom Line

In most parts of the country it’s more likely than not that prior bad acts by your assailant won’t be allowed in evidence if you go to trial. This will make it all the more important for you to be able to articulate what you did know at the moment you had to use force in defense of yourself or other innocent persons. You want to be able to convince a jury of ordinary, reasonable and prudent people that if they knew what you knew at the moment, they would have pulled the trigger, too.

Didn't find what you were looking for?

MOST POPULAR

Vote & Win: 2023 Ballistic’s Best Readers’ Choice for Best Guns

Suicide by Cop

WINCHESTER’s SXP ‘Defender’ Pump Shotgun

10 Pocket Pistols Perfect for Christmas [2023]

Holiday Safety Pat McNamara lead Christmas

The ‘No Snowflake’ Guide to Holiday Safety

TRENDING

cmmg mutant iraqveteran8888 meltdown test

VIDEO: CMMG Mutant Outlasts AK by 355 Rounds in Meltdown Test

magnum research, magnum research desert eagle, desert eagle, Mark XIX L5

Magnum Research Introduces New Lightweight Desert Eagles

The Adams Arms AA19.

Perfect Polymer Player? Shooting the Adams Arms AA19

The XTech Tactical MTX 365 Magazine Extender.

XTech Tactical MTX 365 3-Round Sig P365 Magazine Extender

BROWSE BY BRAND

Skillset-Logo_yellow-153x47png
Ballistic_LOGO-217x47
CH-Logo_blue-153x47
T-L-SS-stack life-47x140
PDW_CCH_LOGO-300x101
PDW-2022-Sidebyside-logo 160x30-blk
GOW LOGO x101
AF_LOGO-184x47

SPOTLIGHT

The Caracal USA Enhanced F Pistol.

Caracal USA Enhanced F Pistol: Designed with a Combative Edge

Proudly made in the USA, Caracal USA announces its Enhanced F pistol in multiple configurations and colors. Designed with...

RELATED POSTS

The Caracal USA Enhanced F Pistol.

Caracal USA Enhanced F Pistol: Designed with a Combative Edge

...

The Beretta M9A4.

The Beretta M9A4 Review: The Optic Ready M9 variant

...

The PTR Archon Firearms Line.

PTR Archon Firearms Lower the Bore Axis for Faster Follow-Up

...

Load More

TRENDING

smith & wesson m&p shield accessories

4 Accessories to Trick Out Your Smith & Wesson M&P Shield

Smith & Wesson’s M&P Shield pistols have been some of the most popular handguns introduced in the past decade. Single-stack...

Suicide by Cop

WINCHESTER’s SXP ‘Defender’ Pump Shotgun

Tactical-Life.com brings you the newest products live from the NASGW ‘08 show!

10 Pocket Pistols Perfect for Christmas [2023]

Santa Claus is coming to town...to deliver these 10 pocket pistols from Remington, Ruger, Glock and many more!

The Standard Manufacturing Damascus 1911.

Damn Sweet: Standard Manufacturing Damascus 1911 Review

You’ve worked hard all your life, and though it hasn’t been all puppies and rainbows, fortunately, there have been more...

MOST POPULAR

The Mossberg MC2sc semi-auto pistol.

12 Best Micro-Compact Handguns for Concealed Carry [2022]

A thick veil of fog stood forever in front of me as I cruised down the highway at 6:30 in...

Police Sidearms, police duty pistols, Handguns, America's Largest Police Departments 2018

Police Sidearms: Handguns of America’s 10 Largest Departments

Law enforcement in the United States is in constant evolution and that includes various police sidearms. These days, law enforcement...

Vote & Win: 2023 Ballistic’s Best Readers’ Choice for Best Guns

One of our most anticipated magazines each year, the 2023 edition of Ballistic's Best, hits the press soon. But first,...

All the best new handguns seen at SHOT Show 2023.

21 Best New Handguns [2023]

The NSSF SHOT Show is the premier event to get your hands on new gear. It gives us a first...

VIDEO SERIES: AT THE READY | SEASON 2

MORE VIDEOS

The Caracal USA Enhanced F Pistol.

Caracal USA Enhanced F Pistol: Designed with a Combative Edge

Savage Arms AccuCan line of suppressors.

Savage Arms AccuCan: New Multi-Caliber Suppressor Line

HANDGUNS

The Caracal USA Enhanced F Pistol.

Caracal USA Enhanced F Pistol: Designed with a Combative Edge

The Beretta M9A4.

The Beretta M9A4 Review: The Optic Ready M9 variant

Ruger Super Redhawk in .22 Hornet

Ruger Super Redhawk Adds .22 Hornet for Varmints & Small Game

The PTR Archon Firearms Line.

PTR Archon Firearms Lower the Bore Axis for Faster Follow-Up

The History of Beretta and its semi-auto pistols.

History of Beretta: Nearly 500 Years of Iconic & Martial Arms

The Taurus TS9 was developed for the military and police market and was adopted by the Philippine National Police.

The Taurus TS9 9mm Pistol Excels in Concealed Carry: Review

RIFLES - click to see all

The Extar USA EP9 Pistol-Caliber Carbine.

The Extar USA EP9 Carbine Accepts Glock G19 & G17 Magazines

Barrett MRADELR rifle.

Barrett MRADELR: The Extreme Long-Range MRAD is Here!

Savage Arms KLYM Series rifles.

Savage Arms KLYM Series Rifles Include PROOF, FBT Components

The MDC VOLK-S AK-47.

The MDC VOLK-S Changes the Game with 100% US-Made AK-47

AMMO - click to see all

Magtech Steel Case 9mm

Magtech Steel Case 9mm Brings Affordable Pistol, PCC Ammo

X-DEF Line from Freedom Munitions Expands with the Addition of .357 Sig.

Freedom Munitions X-DEF Line Adds .357 Sig Self-Defense Ammo

HEVI-Shot HEVI-Bismuth Upland loads.

HEVI-Shot HEVI-Bismuth Upland Expands Hunting Lineup

Ammo Storage, Survival Ammo, long term ammo storage, Prepper

Best Methods for Long-Term Ammo Storage

6 .410 Ammo Options for Home and Personal Defense.

.410 Ammo for Home Defense [2023]

410 bore revolvers for self defense

6 Best .410 Bore Revolvers

No Result
View All Result
  • Guns
    • Handguns
      • Semi-Automatic Handguns
      • Revolvers
    • AR Pistols
    • AR Rifles
    • Rifles
      • Semi-Automatic Rifles
      • Lever Action
      • Bolt Action
    • Shotguns
    • Airguns
    • Custom Guns
      • Handgun Build
      • Rifle Build
      • Shotgun Build
    • Specialty Guns
  • Parts
    • Handgun Parts
    • Rifle Parts
  • Accessories
    • Optics & Sights
      • Thermal Vision
    • Lasers & Lights
    • Suppressors
    • Holsters
    • Slings
    • Shooting Rests
    • Targets
    • Maintenance & Tools
  • Ammo
    • Handgun Ammo
      • 9mm
      • 10mm
    • Rifle Ammo
      • .223
    • Shotgun Ammo
      • 12 Gauge
    • Rimfire Ammo
    • Reloading
  • Gear
    • Apparel
    • Ears & Eyes
      • Ears
      • Eyes
    • Storage
    • Tactical Gear
      • Body Armor
    • Knives
      • Fixed Blade
      • Folding Knives
      • Tactical Knives
    • Less Lethal
    • Flashlights
    • Electronics
  • Lifestyle
    • Concealed Carry
    • Personal Defense
      • Self-Defense
      • Hand to Hand Combat
    • Home Defense
    • Sport Shooting
      • Hunting
      • Competition Shooting
    • Precision Shooting/Long Range Shooting
    • Training
      • Shooting 101
    • Survival
      • First Aid
    • Tactical & LE
    • Military Lifestyle
    • Pop Culture
      • People
      • Rides
      • History
  • News
    • New Products & Industry News
    • Gun Facts & Laws
    • Police News
    • Military News
    • Politics
  • VIDEOS

© 2023 Athlon Outdoors - Premium Firearm product and industry news, reviews and magazines" .